write a research proposapal on the relation of renewable energy to conventional energy – oil gas) through cases studies of two courtiers – European courtiers Germany and gulf courtiers -Qatar the research proposal cover two section 1- literature review 2- research methodology . no need for introduction just write directly as follow : – literature review / 1- to state Germany position on renewable energy by critical scholars views 2- to evulate it depancy on gas importing for gulf / singing the last agreement of Qatar to provide Germany with gas , through indicating reprt scholars views on it . additionally , to address although Germany accelerate toward renewable energy it reminded dependency on conventional energy . all these point of litreature must support by scholars views + the style of writing the literature review must be critical and create tension in the text. the references used for litreture review must be up to date research methodology / to write a methodology that hold a political economy apporch ( therieos name it clery ) that is related to evaluate renewable energy using quantitively method . date that are derived from governmental and institutional date . to evaluate renewable energy in term of its effectives in Germany and to what degree it remind dependency on gas importing.